As6453

What makes BSNL AS9829 as most unstable ASN in the world?!

Anurag Bhatia

On weekend  I was looking at BGP Instability Report data. As usual (and unfortunately) BSNL tops that list. BSNL is the most unstable autonomous network in the world. In past, I have written previously about how AS9829 is the rotten IP backbone.

This isn’t a surprise since they keep on coming on top but I think it’s well worth a check on what exactly is causing that. So I looked into BGP tables updates published on Oregon route-views from 21st May to 27th May and pulled data specifically for AS9829. I see zero withdrawals which are very interesting. I thought there would be a lot of announcements & withdrawals as they switch transits to balance traffic. If I plot the data, I get following chart of withdrawals against timestamp. This consists of summarised view of every 15mins and taken from 653 routing update dumps. It seems not feasible to graph data for 653 dumps, so I picked top 300.

BSNL routing glitch and updates

Anurag Bhatia

Today I noticed some traffic on my blog from a link from Broadband forum

Here’s what poster wrote:

I made a thread a few days ago complaining about BSNL’s horrible routing. Well it looks like it has been fixed. I thank all the guys who made efforts to bring this to BSNL’s notice. Especially Anurag Bhatia who highlighted the issue with much detail on his blog

Softlayer connectivity problem and possible fix.

BSNL - Softlayer connectivity problem & possible fix

Anurag Bhatia

It’s late night here in India. I am having final 8th semester exams and as usual really bored! 

Though this time we have interesting subjects but still syllabus is pretty boring spreading across multiple books, notes and pdf’s. Anyways I will be out of college after June which sounds good.

Tonight, I found a routing glitch. Yes a routing glitch!! :)

These issues somehow keep my life in orbit and give a good understanding on how routing works over the Internet.

Backend of Google's Public DNS

Anurag Bhatia

And finally academic session over. Done with all vivas and related stuff. Next will be exams likely in June. Time for me to get ready for travel. :)   Anyways an interesting topic for today’s post - Google Public DNS. Lot of us are familier with popular (and free) DNS resolvers 8.8.8.8 and 8.8.4.4. I have covered reason in previous posts on why it tends to fail with Content Delivery networks like Akamai which rely on anycasting at bottom DNS layer and simple unicasting on application servers. Anycasted DNS nodes point to application servers based on various factors like distance, load, cost etc out of interesting algorithms these CDN networks use for load & cost management.   Anyways today’s post focus is not CDN issues with these resolvers but Google Public DNS itself. Are these servers located in India and everywhere else where Google has PoPs?   Let’s do a simple trace to get forward path from Airtel to Google’s 8.8.8.8:

BSNL routing tables and upstreams

Anurag Bhatia

Just was looking at routing tables of BSNL. They have a significant address space in /10 - 117.192.0.0/10. Overall this /10 address space is divided into /18 and /20 subnets.

Let’s pick two of such subnets and observe routing tables from route-views:

  1. 117.192.0.0/18
  2. 117.192.0.0/20 

Routing table for 117.192.0.0/18

* 117.192.0.0/18 193.0.0.56 0 3333 3356 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 194.85.102.33 0 3277 3216 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 194.85.40.15 0 3267 174 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 129.250.0.11 6 0 2914 6453 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 128.223.253.10 0 3582 3701 3356 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 4.69.184.193 0 0 3356 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 209.124.176.223 0 101 101 3356 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 69.31.111.244 3 0 4436 2914 6453 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 207.46.32.34 0 8075 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 66.59.190.221 0 6539 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 12.0.1.63 0 7018 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 208.74.64.40 0 19214 2828 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 203.181.248.168 0 7660 2516 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 66.185.128.48 111 0 1668 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 134.222.87.1 0 286 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 157.130.10.233 0 701 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 114.31.199.1 0 0 4826 6939 1299 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 89.149.178.10 10 0 3257 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 154.11.98.225 0 0 852 3561 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 202.249.2.86 0 7500 2497 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 154.11.11.113 0 0 852 3561 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 144.228.241.130 0 1239 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 217.75.96.60 0 0 16150 1299 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 207.172.6.20 0 0 6079 3356 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 206.24.210.102 0 3561 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 195.66.232.239 0 5459 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 208.51.134.254 2523 0 3549 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 207.172.6.1 0 0 6079 3356 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 216.218.252.164 0 6939 1299 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 203.62.252.186 0 1221 4637 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
*> 66.110.0.86 0 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 164.128.32.11 0 3303 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i  
* 202.232.0.2 0 2497 6453 4755 9829 9829 9829 i

Routing table for 117.192.0.0/20: